Hunt The SPADS - fun for all the family

The late and unlamented Michael Gove had the repulsive Brexiteer Dominic Cummings as his SPAD. Nicky Morgan's SPAD was the sweaty Jonathan Simons. I don't think Justine Greening has one yet but Theresa May certainly does - bearded, balding Nick Timothy.

So what?

We tend to assume that Secretaries of State for Education actually care about the subject and occasionally know something about it or at least make a minimal effort to inform themselves about it. I really don't think they do. When you read the White and Green Papers published under their reigns and compare them to the ideas of their SPADS, you often notice a very strong correlation.

For example, "Primary Focus: The next stage of improvement for primary schools in England", written by Annaliese Briggs and Jonathan Simons (September 2014) advocated mass academisation as the only solution for the nation's schools. Once Nicky Morgan was Education Secretary she published her ill-fated White Paper "Educational Excellence Everywhere" which - guess what? - advocated forced mass academisation as the only solution for the nation's schools. Which, unsurprisingly, met mass resistance and was quickly dropped.

Until very recently Nick Timothy was a director of New Schools Network pressure group which was a fervent proponent of free schools. He is a passionate believer in selective education. 77 new free schools were recently announced and then the laughingly-titled "Schools that work for everyone" Green Paper came out and guess what? It advocated the expansion of selective education as the only solution for the nation's schools. It has already met with fierce opposition from a very broad spectrum of critics, including Gove and Morgan. I can't see it surviving, somehow.

Going back to Cummings, who we can all thank for leading the Vote Leave campaign and creating the appalling mess we're all now in, he too worked at the New Schools Network for a while and set up his own free school. Working as Mr Nasty behind the reportedly charming Michael Gove, he developed a reputation as being "either mad, bad or brilliant - and probably a bit of all three" (Patrick Wintour) and a "career psychopath" (David Cameron). It is harder to detect his influence on Gove's 2010 White Paper "The Importance of Teaching" because it came out remarkably quickly after the Coalition election victory and has Gove's fingerprints all over it. To be fair to Gove, which hurts me physically and mentally, his White Paper is a model of clearly argued, coherent policy, especially compared to Morgan's and the new Green Paper. That does, I think, qualify as faint praise and is a measure of how far we've fallen as a nation.

Are we seeing a pattern here? I make a point of reading the education papers published by various Think Tanks, most of which, frustratingly, tend to be right wing. What seems to me to characterise them is that they are often written by people who have no serious or deep experience of a wide range of schools and therefore never spot the flaws in their glistening new ideas which would be obvious to anyone who has worked in the real education system for a few years.

In their enthusiasm to come up with something radical and new, they are also very cavalier with their research findings (including "self-reporting", for example, as a supposedly valid approach to data collection) and sample sizes. The very recent "Academy Chains Unlocked" (published by Reform) bases its radical arguments on a survey of the Chief Executives of Academy Chains - a somewhat self-interested group, I would suggest. At no point does it say clearly that the number of usable responses they received (66) represents a mere 2% of all academy chain CEOs (3064) but they are happy to develop their arguments on the basis of a pathetically tiny "evidence base".

"Academy Chains Unlocked" has already been overtaken by events - the reintroduction of selective schools, so will probably sink without trace. But at the same time a new army of academy zealots has emerged, fighting for the Gove-Morgan-Cameron-Osborne vision of mass academisation (see this schools week article). Never mind "Game of Thrones" - this is starting to look like the real battle of the bastards.

Of course, people working in real schools are too busy or too knackered to plough through the nonsense produced by too many Think Tanks, so they don't receive the robust challenge they deserve and their sparkly authors tend to get promoted to SPAD status, as if publishing a fantasy were evidence of clear political thinking and some kind of valuable wisdom. Education Secretaries unsullied by real experience or understanding of education welcome them with open arms, encourage them to force their untested ideas on education policy and then, too late, realise that they know nothing and now have egg all over their Ministerial face.

It's a repeating pattern. I hope that Justine Greening, the supposed Education Secretary, has noticed this and does something to avoid repeating the same mistakes, for her sake, but more importantly for the sake of our poor schoolkids. Then again, Theresa's in charge of education policy, isn't she? Or is it Nick Timothy?

I think we should be told.

 

 

News Archive page link

You can see all the articles archived from this page by visiting the News Archive

 

 

Search link

Quotes

Professional and affordable support and challenge

  • Are you looking for an independent review of your governing body?
  • Do you need quality clerking?
  • Can't find the training and development you need?

Click here for professional,
affordable support and challenge

Downloads page link

Videos page link

Links page link

Mailing List link

About Me page link

Search this site:-


Loading

 

Recent updates:-

23 Sep 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Hunt The SPADS - fun for all the family'

23 Sep 2016

New document 'Academy-chains-unlocked.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

13 Sep 2016

New document 'Schools that work for everyone.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

12 Sep 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'The return of the dead cat'

31 Aug 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'A new school year begins...and Winter Is Coming'

28 Jul 2016

New document 'Taxpayers fund large wages and lavish perks of academy school chiefs.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

18 Jul 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Could we have some order, please?'

18 Jul 2016

2 new documents 'MAT performance measures DfE 2016.pdf' and 'Chain-Effects-2016.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

4 Jul 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Reprise: who's a naughty boy, then?'

4 Jul 2016

New document 'Analysis of academy performance in 2015 NFER report.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

27 Jun 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Lost for words part 2'

11 May 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'I told you so...'

11 May 2016

New document 'State of Education survey report 2016.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

22 Apr 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'It's dead but it keeps on twitching'

22 Apr 2016

2 new downloads 'NUT-rebuttal-10-facts-you-need-to-know-about-academies.pdf' and 'Every school an academy HoC commentary.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

22 Apr 2016

2 new downloads 'DfE-consolidated-annual-report-and-a-counts-2014-to-2015.pdf' and 'The-Report-of-the-Comptroller-and-Auditor-General on-the-DfEs-2014-15-financial-statement.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

2 Apr 2016

2 new downloads 'Parents out.pdf' and 'School academy plan.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

21 Mar 2016

Home page updated with new news article: '12 reasons why mass academisation will never happen'.

21 Mar 2016

New document 'Educational_excellence_everywhere.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

17 Mar 2016

Home page updated with new news article: Great 'who'd have guessed it' headlines of our time number 32: Tories nationalise education.

15 Feb 2016

Home page updated with new news article 'Lost for words'.

31 Jan 2016

2 new downloads 'HoC on RSCs Jan 2016.pdf' added to the Academies section and 'State_of_the_nation_2015 social_mobility_and_child_poverty_in_Great_Britain.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

03 Dec 2015

New download 'Ofsted_annual_report_education_and_skills.pdf' added to the Ofsted section on the downloads page.

30 Nov 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Welcome to the DfA'.

30 Nov 2015

New download 'Governance_Handbook_Nov_2015.pdf' added to the Governors Handbook section on the downloads page - replaces previous Jan 2015 version (note the name change from Governors to Governance).

21 Nov 2015

Home page updated with new news article '21st century governance needed for 21st century schools'.

21 Nov 2015

New download 'Isolated_schools_Out_on_a_limb.pdf' added to the School performance section on the downloads page.

6 Nov 2015

4 new downloads added to the Pupil Premium section on the downloads page - 'Effective_support_for_disadvantaged_pupils__achievement.pdf',
'DFE-RR411 Supporting the attainment of disadvantaged pupils.pdf',
'DFE-RB411 Supporting the attainment of disadvantaged pupils brief.pdf', and
'DFE-RS411 Supporting the attainment of disadvantaged pupils - briefing for school leaders.pdf'

23 Oct 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Back to the future'.

23 Oct 2015

New download 'extending-the-early-years-entitlement-costings-concerns-and-alternatives.pdf' added to the Finance and Managing resources section on the downloads page.

23 Oct 2015

New download 'An-Unholy-Mess.pdf' added to the Admissions section on the downloads page.

23 Oct 2015

New download 'Guide to Regional Schools Commissioners.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

18 Sep 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Chipping away at a bad bill'.

24 Aug 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Silly season'.

28 July 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Wilful blindness... or a cunning plan?'.

28 July 2015

New download 'Chain-Effects-2015.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

14 July 2015

Downloads page reorganised to move related documents to the new Pupil Premium section.

7 July 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Democracy in Action?'.

7 July 2015

New Pupil Premium section added to the downloads page along with 2 new downloads 'Funding-for-disadvantaged-pupils.pdf' and 'Pupil_Premium_Summit_Report.pdf'.

7 July 2015

New download 'LGGA03.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

23 June 2015

New Religion and Belief section added to the downloads page along with new download 'A-New-Settlement-for-Religion-and-Belief-in-schools.pdf'.

17 June 2015

New downloads 'The_common_inspection_framework_education_skills_and_early_years.pdf', 'School_inspection_handbook_section_8.pdf' and 'School_inspection_handbook_from_September_2015.pdf' added to the Ofsted section on the downloads page.

17 June 2015

Home page updated with link to my intro leaflet.

17 June 2015

My intro leaflet on the About Me page updated.

11 Jun 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'The silent revolution (will not be televised)'.

8 Jun 2015

New download 'Barely_under_Control.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

19 May 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Coasting towards the waterfall'

12 May 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Post-match analysis'.

23 Apr 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Shhhh...don't mention education'.

23 Apr 2015

About Me page updated.

12 Apr 2015

New look website launched.

24 Mar 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Greek and other myths'.

24 Mar 2015

New download 'Trojan Horse report.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

14 Mar 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'A castle built on sand (surrounded by a rising tide)'.

14 Mar 2015

New download 'a rising tide.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

20 Feb 2015

New download 'THE-MOVE-BEYOND-EFFECTIVE-(Research).pdf' added to the Recent reports on Governance section on the downloads page.

9 Feb 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'The DfE gets a good kicking'.

9 Feb 2015

New download 'School-Oversight-and-intervention-January-2015.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

30 Jan 2015

News archive page updated (broken link to the observer updated as they have moved their site).

30 Jan 2015

Download updated: 'National_Standards_of_Excellence_for_Headteachers.pdf' added to the Heads and Governors section on the downloads page to replace the 2004 version.

30 Jan 2015

Download updated: 'Twenty-questions-second-edition-2015-v2.pdf' added to the 20 Questions for governing bodies section on the downloads page to replace the 2012 version.

30 Jan 2015

New download 'Framework-for-Governance.pdf' added to a new Strategic planning section on the downloads page.

30 Jan 2015

Download updated: 'Governors_Handbook_Jan_2015.pdf' added to the Governors Handbook section on the downloads page to replace the May 2014 version.

30 Jan 2015

New download 'Academies and free schools.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

30 Jan 2015

New download 'sir-david-bell-ASE-2015-speech-9-january.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

back to top of page