Better late than never?

"It is a morality tale of opportunism and greed...and one thing leading to another, in a typically unplanned British way, on the part of successive governments."

Who said that and about what?

Andrew Adonis, about student fees, in The Guardian on 8 July 2017.

I expect you will recall that Adonis was the architect of the policy and expert on vigabatrin rems. I admire him for admitting after all these years that the system has failed and doesn't deserve to survive. Though, of course, he will never be held to account for it and nor will his successors. Which is why these disasters continue to happen.

What is unforgivable, though, is his utter naivety in assuming that when the government said that £3000 was the maximum that universities could charge for a course, the vast majority of courses would cost a lot less than that. When the cap was raised to £9000 under the Coalition, surprise, surprise, all degree course suddenly cost £9000. I don't know anyone that would not have assumed the opposite: that if you set a maximum, that's what universities will charge as the norm. It is blindingly obvious. How could he and the Blair government not foresee it? Plenty of critics of the policy at the time pointed this out but were ignored.

Adonis now condemns Vice Chancellors as being greedy. I don't doubt for a moment that they are. People at the top of most organisations these days do tend to be, don't they? He asks, with the bewilderment of a small child, "why did we give university vice-chancellors a licence to print money, and pay themselves £400,000 salaries, in a decade when austerity has dominated every other public service, including schools and hospitals?" Forget the we, Andrew. We had no say in it. It was you and malfunctioning politicians like you, who seem to understand nothing about how the world works.

It is now clear - and has been for many years to anyone with an interest in education - that most student loans will never be repaid. That means that we pay, we taxpayers. We taxpayers who previously funded the much cheaper and more effective system of grants. The grants system that Adonis and his friends overturned because...? It was one possible strategy to address the issue of "seriously underfunded universities trying to work out a survival strategy in the face of Margaret Thatcher's dislike of all things public sector." In other words, an ideological solution, rather than a pragmatic one in the public interest.

But what worries me as much, if not more, is that Adonis was also the architect of the academies system.

How long will it be before he admits that this, too, was a massive mistake?

Conditions similar to the student fees debacle were set up for the abuse and failure of the academies system, again because of naivety or wilful ignoring of its many critics. This is not to say that all academies and all academy leaders are villains - clearly not. But if you trumpet that academies offer new freedoms from previous safeguards (or, rather, "red tape") and autonomy, some crooks and charlatans will see plenty of opportunities to rip off the taxpayer. It would be naive, wouldn't it, to assume that everyone attracted to setting up an education empire funded by the state would be motivated by the purest ethics rather than personal gain?

There has been a steady stream of horror stories especially in MATs, where standards have either not improved or fallen but chief executives continue to pay themselves ever larger salaries. Some academy leaders have been jailed for fraud. Schools Week reported today (July 10th) that "Over 90% of investigations into academy finances are a result of whistleblowers"...It comes as an investigation published last week found the Rodillian Multi Academy Trust, which runs four schools in Yorkshire, broke the rules when it paid nearly £8,000 for its chief executive to stay in a four-star hotel for 78 nights, despite claims he lived within travelling distance...Whistleblowers have prompted three investigations this year, one last year, six in 2014-15, and four in 2013-14. They included tip-offs about schools falsely recording pupils who received free school meals, a chief executive buying personal items and presents for relatives on the trust's credit card, salary overpayments and safeguarding failures."

If you want to check out the truth of what I'm saying, read Schools Week for yourself. These stories almost never make the national media but they keep coming. If they were all to happen at the same time, there would, I hope, be a national outcry, but because they continue to trickle through and are not properly reported, everything seems OK and politicians continue to lie and are unchallenged about the supposed merits of the system over its predecessor.

What will it take for Adonis to face reality and admit that the academies programme is, at best, only a partial success and, at worst, as big a scandal and waste of public money as the student fees fiasco? I fear that he still believes that it's all been a massive success...

I'm prepared to wait a few more years before he finally writes about the academies programme that "It is a morality tale of opportunism and greed...and one thing leading to another, in a typically unplanned British way, on the part of successive governments."


 

News Archive page link

 

You can see all the articles archived from this page by visiting the News Archive

 

 

Search link

Quotes

Professional and affordable support and challenge

  • Are you looking for an independent review of your governing body?
  • Do you need quality clerking?
  • Can't find the training and development you need?

Click here for professional,
affordable support and challenge

Downloads page link

Videos page link

Links page link

About Us page link

Mailing List link

Search this site:-


Loading

 

Recent updates:-

10 Jul 2017

Home page updated with new news article: Better late than never?

3 Jul 2017

Home page updated with new news article: Making sense of chaos.

22 Jun 2017

Home page updated with new news article: Challenging the status quo.

12 Jun 2017

Home page updated with new news article: Reasons to be cheerful, Part 17.

15 May 2017

Home page updated with new news article: Back from wherever.

24 April 2017

About us page updated.

24 April 2017

Navigation menu updated.

2 March 2017

2 new documents added to the downloads page. 'MATs HoC report Feb 2017.pdf' added to the Academies section and 'Selective-Comprehensives-2017.pdf' added to the Admissions section.

13 Feb 2017

Home page updated with new news article: Grammars are go! (not).

19 Jan 2017

Home page updated with new news article: The DfE has finally done something good...

16 Jan 2017

2 new documents 'Governance_Handbook_January_2017.pdf' and 'Competency_framework_for_governance.pdf' added to the Governors Handbook section on the downloads page.

19 Dec 2016

Home page updated with new news article: Improving Ofsted reports on improving governance.

19 Dec 2016

New download 'Improving Governance.pdf' added to the Ofsted section on the downloads page.

12 Dec 2016

2 new documents added to the downloads page. 'Gaps-in-Grammar.pdf' added to the Government Policy section and 'Pupil_characteristics_and_performance_at_faith_schools.pdf' added to the Religion and Belief section.

5 Dec 2016

Home page updated with new news article: Bye bye, Sir Michael.

15 Nov 2016

Home page updated with new news article: Time to admit defeat?

13 Oct 2016

Home page updated with new news article: Academies - some good news for once?

13 Oct 2016

New document 'Wilshaw on the best MATs.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

29 Sep 2016

New section '14-19 Education' added to the downloads page with 2 new documents '14-19_education_-_a_new_baccalaureate.pdf' and '14-19_education_-_a_new_baccalaureate_-_summary_final.pdf'

29 Sep 2016

Links updated on the links page where websites have moved.

23 Sep 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Hunt The SPADS - fun for all the family'

23 Sep 2016

New document 'Academy-chains-unlocked.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

13 Sep 2016

New document 'Schools that work for everyone.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

12 Sep 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'The return of the dead cat'

31 Aug 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'A new school year begins...and Winter Is Coming'

28 Jul 2016

New document 'Taxpayers fund large wages and lavish perks of academy school chiefs.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

18 Jul 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Could we have some order, please?'

18 Jul 2016

2 new documents 'MAT performance measures DfE 2016.pdf' and 'Chain-Effects-2016.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

4 Jul 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Reprise: who's a naughty boy, then?'

4 Jul 2016

New document 'Analysis of academy performance in 2015 NFER report.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

27 Jun 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'Lost for words part 2'

11 May 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'I told you so...'

11 May 2016

New document 'State of Education survey report 2016.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

22 Apr 2016

Home page updated with new news article: 'It's dead but it keeps on twitching'

22 Apr 2016

2 new downloads 'NUT-rebuttal-10-facts-you-need-to-know-about-academies.pdf' and 'Every school an academy HoC commentary.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

22 Apr 2016

2 new downloads 'DfE-consolidated-annual-report-and-a-counts-2014-to-2015.pdf' and 'The-Report-of-the-Comptroller-and-Auditor-General on-the-DfEs-2014-15-financial-statement.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

2 Apr 2016

2 new downloads 'Parents out.pdf' and 'School academy plan.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

21 Mar 2016

Home page updated with new news article: '12 reasons why mass academisation will never happen'.

21 Mar 2016

New document 'Educational_excellence_everywhere.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

17 Mar 2016

Home page updated with new news article: Great 'who'd have guessed it' headlines of our time number 32: Tories nationalise education.

15 Feb 2016

Home page updated with new news article 'Lost for words'.

31 Jan 2016

2 new downloads 'HoC on RSCs Jan 2016.pdf' added to the Academies section and 'State_of_the_nation_2015 social_mobility_and_child_poverty_in_Great_Britain.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

03 Dec 2015

New download 'Ofsted_annual_report_education_and_skills.pdf' added to the Ofsted section on the downloads page.

30 Nov 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Welcome to the DfA'.

30 Nov 2015

New download 'Governance_Handbook_Nov_2015.pdf' added to the Governors Handbook section on the downloads page - replaces previous Jan 2015 version (note the name change from Governors to Governance).

21 Nov 2015

Home page updated with new news article '21st century governance needed for 21st century schools'.

21 Nov 2015

New download 'Isolated_schools_Out_on_a_limb.pdf' added to the School performance section on the downloads page.

6 Nov 2015

4 new downloads added to the Pupil Premium section on the downloads page - 'Effective_support_for_disadvantaged_pupils__achievement.pdf',
'DFE-RR411 Supporting the attainment of disadvantaged pupils.pdf',
'DFE-RB411 Supporting the attainment of disadvantaged pupils brief.pdf', and
'DFE-RS411 Supporting the attainment of disadvantaged pupils - briefing for school leaders.pdf'

23 Oct 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Back to the future'.

23 Oct 2015

New download 'extending-the-early-years-entitlement-costings-concerns-and-alternatives.pdf' added to the Finance and Managing resources section on the downloads page.

23 Oct 2015

New download 'An-Unholy-Mess.pdf' added to the Admissions section on the downloads page.

23 Oct 2015

New download 'Guide to Regional Schools Commissioners.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

18 Sep 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Chipping away at a bad bill'.

24 Aug 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Silly season'.

28 July 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Wilful blindness... or a cunning plan?'.

28 July 2015

New download 'Chain-Effects-2015.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

14 July 2015

Downloads page reorganised to move related documents to the new Pupil Premium section.

7 July 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Democracy in Action?'.

7 July 2015

New Pupil Premium section added to the downloads page along with 2 new downloads 'Funding-for-disadvantaged-pupils.pdf' and 'Pupil_Premium_Summit_Report.pdf'.

7 July 2015

New download 'LGGA03.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

23 June 2015

New Religion and Belief section added to the downloads page along with new download 'A-New-Settlement-for-Religion-and-Belief-in-schools.pdf'.

17 June 2015

New downloads 'The_common_inspection_framework_education_skills_and_early_years.pdf', 'School_inspection_handbook_section_8.pdf' and 'School_inspection_handbook_from_September_2015.pdf' added to the Ofsted section on the downloads page.

17 June 2015

Home page updated with link to my intro leaflet.

17 June 2015

My intro leaflet on the About Me page updated.

11 Jun 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'The silent revolution (will not be televised)'.

8 Jun 2015

New download 'Barely_under_Control.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

19 May 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Coasting towards the waterfall'

12 May 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Post-match analysis'.

23 Apr 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Shhhh...don't mention education'.

23 Apr 2015

About Me page updated.

12 Apr 2015

New look website launched.

24 Mar 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'Greek and other myths'.

24 Mar 2015

New download 'Trojan Horse report.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

14 Mar 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'A castle built on sand (surrounded by a rising tide)'.

14 Mar 2015

New download 'a rising tide.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

20 Feb 2015

New download 'THE-MOVE-BEYOND-EFFECTIVE-(Research).pdf' added to the Recent reports on Governance section on the downloads page.

9 Feb 2015

Home page updated with new news article 'The DfE gets a good kicking'.

9 Feb 2015

New download 'School-Oversight-and-intervention-January-2015.pdf' added to the Government Policy section on the downloads page.

30 Jan 2015

News archive page updated (broken link to the observer updated as they have moved their site).

30 Jan 2015

Download updated: 'National_Standards_of_Excellence_for_Headteachers.pdf' added to the Heads and Governors section on the downloads page to replace the 2004 version.

30 Jan 2015

Download updated: 'Twenty-questions-second-edition-2015-v2.pdf' added to the 20 Questions for governing bodies section on the downloads page to replace the 2012 version.

30 Jan 2015

New download 'Framework-for-Governance.pdf' added to a new Strategic planning section on the downloads page.

30 Jan 2015

Download updated: 'Governors_Handbook_Jan_2015.pdf' added to the Governors Handbook section on the downloads page to replace the May 2014 version.

30 Jan 2015

New download 'Academies and free schools.pdf' added to the Academies section on the downloads page.

30 Jan 2015

New download 'sir-david-bell-ASE-2015-speech-9-january.pdf' added to the Big picture of education section on the downloads page.

back to top of page